商学院会计金融领域。
因为合作一片文章，认识一个在一个研究学校很不错的一个fresh ph.d。想和她合作一
片文章。发给她我
的想法(introduction section only)。
她回电邮说她的一个朋友正在做几乎一样的topic的文章。Her friend also sent her
the
proposal and asked for comments too. So she cannot work on this with me. Her
friend has already had a co-author and is working on this. 她说她可以开口问
对方可
不可以合并 two projects。我没有信心对方可以接受合并的建议，因为我只是一个
proposal，其他什么
都没有。我也不知道对方什么stage了。
Here is what I plan to do:
Omit the hand-collection and get the data from database directly. Sample
size
will be smaller. Have the working paper posted online and submit to a
journal
and conference. Hopefully we compete and we win, or we are combined by the
journal or the conference.
有人有过类似经验么？我听说过successful stories and sad stories of competing
papers.
It is like a gambling.
s*****w 发帖数: 2065
2
proposal stage...hand-collect....
move on吧，呵呵。
这种事情happen all the time!
her
Her
【在 g******s 的大作中提到】 : 商学院会计金融领域。 : 因为合作一片文章，认识一个在一个研究学校很不错的一个fresh ph.d。想和她合作一 : 片文章。发给她我 : 的想法(introduction section only)。 : 她回电邮说她的一个朋友正在做几乎一样的topic的文章。Her friend also sent her : the : proposal and asked for comments too. So she cannot work on this with me. Her : friend has already had a co-author and is working on this. 她说她可以开口问 : 对方可 : 不可以合并 two projects。我没有信心对方可以接受合并的建议，因为我只是一个
