由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Economics版 - Bad experiences at journals
相关主题
请各位推荐一些宏观经济方面的刊物?Senior Postdoctoral Research Fellowship advert
Top journal third round review 了 138 天 还没有消息Help:Apply for Ph.D in economics
有关 Journal 的问题? just IMHO
Is AER the NO. 1 journal?[转载] 抢鲜预览:Positive Political Theory II
Job openings in the School of Economics, Shanghai University of Finance and EconomicsPolitical business cycles in China?
弱问:Oxford Research of Economic Policy 档次如何?世界上最难的数学竞赛-普特南数学竞赛(读读挺有意思的)
game theory related question..looking for a paper by Akerlof
帮忙选校30岁了想转行经济学是不是有点晚了
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: bad话题: paper话题: journals话题: editor
进入Economics版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
e**l
发帖数: 21
1
Sent a paper to Oxford economic papers, the editor kept it two months
without doing anything. Then I withdrawed my paper.
w****y
发帖数: 53
2
欧洲的journal一向都这样,其实催一下就可以了
e**l
发帖数: 21
3
催了,it did not help.
a**a
发帖数: 8
4
Two months not too reasonable, IMO.
a**a
发帖数: 8
5
I mean to say not too UNreasonable.
e**l
发帖数: 21
6
It was not the paper was under review for 2 months. It was the editor
holding the paper for more than two months without trying to find a referee.
a**a
发帖数: 8
7
I understand, but I don't think that's uncommon ... depending on how
responsible & how busy the editor is.
a**a
发帖数: 8
8
The worst situation is that your paper somehow is lost somewhere in the
procedure. You can confirm (politely) with the secretary in charge that
everything is in order, IMHO.
w****y
发帖数: 53
9
5楼说得很对,经常发生这种情况,两个月不算长。特别是欧洲,还有相对比较老的
journal. OP可能是applied micro的?
e**l
发帖数: 21
10
I lost confidence with the Indian editor: even finally accepted, it could
take three years. So I decided to withdraw the paper and never submit to
the journal again.
1 (共1页)
进入Economics版参与讨论
相关主题
30岁了想转行经济学是不是有点晚了Job openings in the School of Economics, Shanghai University of Finance and Economics
请教有经验的前辈弱问:Oxford Research of Economic Policy 档次如何?
OFFER选择的问题,急~(匿名区)game theory related question..
How to delay the acceptance of a job offer?帮忙选校
请各位推荐一些宏观经济方面的刊物?Senior Postdoctoral Research Fellowship advert
Top journal third round review 了 138 天 还没有消息Help:Apply for Ph.D in economics
有关 Journal 的问题? just IMHO
Is AER the NO. 1 journal?[转载] 抢鲜预览:Positive Political Theory II
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: bad话题: paper话题: journals话题: editor