D******k
发帖数: 335 | 1 两个以前都用过，其实更喜欢Altium Designer 。但是以前有次用Protel DXP 2004的
时候，做一个BGA器件的PCB布线，那么小的间距在做里面的pad布线时死活都有问题，
后来有个人用OrCAD很快就搞定。
但是我发现OrCAD好像特别笨，不如自己以前用Protel时随心所欲。
请问现在布这种普通的4层6层板，用哪个更方便快捷，Altium Designer 还是OrCAD？
现在国内大家都用哪个？谢谢 |
g******u
发帖数: 3060 | 2 I have a lot experience with Orcad 10.5 and Altium 10. I don't like Protel.
I'd say Orcad is good for home projects, not so large pcb, need sth quick.
Altium is better on the company level, a lot better functions you can use. |
D******k
发帖数: 335 | 3 请问你用哪个布线器？
【在 g******u 的大作中提到】
: I have a lot experience with Orcad 10.5 and Altium 10. I don't like Protel.
: I'd say Orcad is good for home projects, not so large pcb, need sth quick.
: Altium is better on the company level, a lot better functions you can use.
|
a********e
发帖数: 381 | 4
Orcad + Allegro is one of the most powerful industry-level design suites,
not merely for home project.
I'd say Altium designer is a good choice because it is easy to learn.
【在 g******u 的大作中提到】
: I have a lot experience with Orcad 10.5 and Altium 10. I don't like Protel.
: I'd say Orcad is good for home projects, not so large pcb, need sth quick.
: Altium is better on the company level, a lot better functions you can use.
|
D******k
发帖数: 335 | 5 我以前用Altium的时候感觉确实很方便，布线是很方便 随心所欲。但是那个BGA的过孔
怎么也达不到要求的分辨率和精度，把我给郁闷坏了。
我公司里面用的最基本的OrCAD,那个OrCAD Layout 是在太差了，非常不方便。不知道
Allergo用起来方便吗？
【在 a********e 的大作中提到】
:
: Orcad + Allegro is one of the most powerful industry-level design suites,
: not merely for home project.
: I'd say Altium designer is a good choice because it is easy to learn.
|
H******u
发帖数: 36 | 6 同意，PADS才是专业布线，想必Altium来说。 |
g******u
发帖数: 3060 | 7 以前杂志上介绍一伙人画个一万还是几万元件的板，用个软件可以把板子分割成几块然
后分头画，忘记是哪个了。 |
g******u
发帖数: 3060 | 8 我用orcad是很老的10.5，现在的版本不会用。但是呆家里设计点小东西很足够。
【在 a********e 的大作中提到】
:
: Orcad + Allegro is one of the most powerful industry-level design suites,
: not merely for home project.
: I'd say Altium designer is a good choice because it is easy to learn.
|
