由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Bridge版 - how do you play this 3H?
相关主题
3NT at BBO【每周一题】Kill Point
how to bid【每周一题】GNT-Open 实战牌例
【每周一题】第九墩牌Some thoughts on one hand
Bidding question IIIWhat do you discard?
Look at this handBridge question! (转载)
叫牌问题(11)BBO的IMP PAIR记分规则
【每周一题】概率打法Who play at BBO?
【每周一题】保留选择Re: A hand on BBO.
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: east话题: play话题: hk话题: west话题: 9830
进入Bridge版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
i****e
发帖数: 642
1
W N E S
P P 3♣ 3♥
P P P
♠KQ1052
♥974
♦82
♣832
♠8
♥AQJ863
♦KQ4
♣1094
You are a world star sitting south, and play 3♥. West leads ♣Q,
east overtakes with K, and returns ♦6. West wins your ♦K, and
returns ♦T, east follows ♦7.
What do you play next?
b***y
发帖数: 2804
2
Play a spade?
b***y
发帖数: 2804
3
Also, is this MP or IMP? Are we playing on BBO with self-rated World Class,
or real stars?
i****e
发帖数: 642
4
It is IMP, if it matters. It is at BBO, but you are REAL World Star. Your
opponents may not be very strong, but they qualify to sit at your table :)
Don't you think a spade play is so obvious that it can be wrong :) Or let
me ask this way, do you think about any other play?

,

【在 b***y 的大作中提到】
: Also, is this MP or IMP? Are we playing on BBO with self-rated World Class,
: or real stars?

b***y
发帖数: 2804
5
Well, I will play a spade at the table. Maybe that's why I am not a real
world star. :-)
I don't think East will hold SA, so I see no danger in playing a spade. I do
have a problem if West ducks SA.

【在 i****e 的大作中提到】
: It is IMP, if it matters. It is at BBO, but you are REAL World Star. Your
: opponents may not be very strong, but they qualify to sit at your table :)
: Don't you think a spade play is so obvious that it can be wrong :) Or let
: me ask this way, do you think about any other play?
:
: ,

p***r
发帖数: 20570
6
Some players at the bidding stage did something strange. If west didn't pass
with 12 or more HCP, your only chance would be to play him to hold SA, DA
CQ and east opens 3C with at least 12 HCPS. So it's generally safe to play S
here, try to set up dummy.
If west ducks, you can win SK, take H finesse, ruff D, take another H
finesse to make it. If west plays SA and returns D, you have to ruff, cash
SK then take H finesse. You would make it when east holds SJxx HK DJxx
CAKJxxx or Sxx HK DJxxx CAKJxxx or Sxx HKx DJxx CAKJxxx. Here you can't cash
SQ, because east may ruff it with stiff HK to defeat it.
Playing something other than S is strange. You can cash HA, but it fails
when east hold HKx and only good when somebody holds stiff HK. You can ruff
D, that would cost you an entry to cash your S winner. So it's only good
when west holds something like AJxxxxx Hxx DATx CQ, which is a long shot.

【在 i****e 的大作中提到】
: W N E S
: P P 3♣ 3♥
: P P P
: ♠KQ1052
: ♥974
: ♦82
: ♣832
: ♠8
: ♥AQJ863
: ♦KQ4

p***r
发帖数: 20570
7
If he ducks, you can just take H finesse to make it. East has to hold HK,
otherwise, west passed with SA HK DA CQ

do

【在 b***y 的大作中提到】
: Well, I will play a spade at the table. Maybe that's why I am not a real
: world star. :-)
: I don't think East will hold SA, so I see no danger in playing a spade. I do
: have a problem if West ducks SA.

i****e
发帖数: 642
8

There are so many strange things happened on the table. Bidding is a little
strange as you mentioned. I don't see any reason why east did not cash one
more club. If he cashed clubs, declarer would not have any chance.
I don't see any good reason not to play S after winning DQ. But south played
HA, dropped east's K. It is still not late to play S. But declarer ruffed D
, so there was no entry to dummy anymore.
Does south look like a world star? That is the reason I am posting the hand
here.
Can I guess Garozzo's BBO account was hacked? :)

【在 p***r 的大作中提到】
: If he ducks, you can just take H finesse to make it. East has to hold HK,
: otherwise, west passed with SA HK DA CQ
:
: do

p***r
发帖数: 20570
9
He's very old now and may make quite a few mistakes.

little
played
D
hand

【在 i****e 的大作中提到】
:
: There are so many strange things happened on the table. Bidding is a little
: strange as you mentioned. I don't see any reason why east did not cash one
: more club. If he cashed clubs, declarer would not have any chance.
: I don't see any good reason not to play S after winning DQ. But south played
: HA, dropped east's K. It is still not late to play S. But declarer ruffed D
: , so there was no entry to dummy anymore.
: Does south look like a world star? That is the reason I am posting the hand
: here.
: Can I guess Garozzo's BBO account was hacked? :)

b***y
发帖数: 2804
10
Or maybe just distracted. Lots of things can happen with online game, maybe
he was talking on a phone with a girlfriend. :-)

【在 p***r 的大作中提到】
: He's very old now and may make quite a few mistakes.
:
: little
: played
: D
: hand

相关主题
叫牌问题(11)【每周一题】Kill Point
【每周一题】概率打法【每周一题】GNT-Open 实战牌例
【每周一题】保留选择Some thoughts on one hand
进入Bridge版参与讨论
i****e
发帖数: 642
11
But the mistake is such a low level one, and I thought I must have missed
something at beginning. For Garozzo, I don't expect such kind of mistake
even if he is old, or is talking to girlfriend over phone :)

maybe

【在 b***y 的大作中提到】
: Or maybe just distracted. Lots of things can happen with online game, maybe
: he was talking on a phone with a girlfriend. :-)

p***r
发帖数: 20570
12
牛人犯的弱智错误多了去了。正式比赛上revoke过的都有不少。

【在 i****e 的大作中提到】
: But the mistake is such a low level one, and I thought I must have missed
: something at beginning. For Garozzo, I don't expect such kind of mistake
: even if he is old, or is talking to girlfriend over phone :)
:
: maybe

b***y
发帖数: 2804
13
Maybe he asked girlfriend to play the hand while he went to restroom. :-)))

missed

【在 i****e 的大作中提到】
: But the mistake is such a low level one, and I thought I must have missed
: something at beginning. For Garozzo, I don't expect such kind of mistake
: even if he is old, or is talking to girlfriend over phone :)
:
: maybe

j*******e
发帖数: 2168
14
girlfriend expert player, sat at east and found the way to give contract
away.
but he knew better.

【在 b***y 的大作中提到】
: Maybe he asked girlfriend to play the hand while he went to restroom. :-)))
:
: missed

p***r
发帖数: 20570
15
他多数时候是和他老婆Lea Du Pont打牌。杜邦家的小姐。

【在 j*******e 的大作中提到】
: girlfriend expert player, sat at east and found the way to give contract
: away.
: but he knew better.

j*x
发帖数: 931
16
I'm not sure if I am missing anything in the discussion. I feel the same way
the player played.
That East didn't cash clubs showed him holding singleton Heart K to over
ruff diamond. If Spade was played, West A, sent a diamond to East. East then
cash two clubs. That would be down 2, right?
b***y
发帖数: 2804
17
Here are the things you missed:
1) East has at least one more diamond. He played D6 first, then D7. If he
had doubleton, he would have played D7 then D6. This is not a time to false-
card, since you will more likely mislead partner.
2) Another clue is that East opened 3C and has shown 6 clubs. If East has
doubleton diamonds plus stiff HK, he will have 4 spades. Not impossible, but
relatively unlikely.
3) In the actual play, HA drops HK, how can it cost to play a spade now?
Instead the declarer ruffed diamond, which is giving up the contract. The
only explanation is that, either declarer mis-clicked, or girlfriend was
playing. :-))

【在 j*x 的大作中提到】
: I'm not sure if I am missing anything in the discussion. I feel the same way
: the player played.
: That East didn't cash clubs showed him holding singleton Heart K to over
: ruff diamond. If Spade was played, West A, sent a diamond to East. East then
: cash two clubs. That would be down 2, right?

j*x
发帖数: 931
18
I see. East cannot ruff diamond.
I totally agree with your 3). Even if East could ruff a diamond, after HK
dropped, it seems to be safe to play spade.

false-
but

【在 b***y 的大作中提到】
: Here are the things you missed:
: 1) East has at least one more diamond. He played D6 first, then D7. If he
: had doubleton, he would have played D7 then D6. This is not a time to false-
: card, since you will more likely mislead partner.
: 2) Another clue is that East opened 3C and has shown 6 clubs. If East has
: doubleton diamonds plus stiff HK, he will have 4 spades. Not impossible, but
: relatively unlikely.
: 3) In the actual play, HA drops HK, how can it cost to play a spade now?
: Instead the declarer ruffed diamond, which is giving up the contract. The
: only explanation is that, either declarer mis-clicked, or girlfriend was

1 (共1页)
进入Bridge版参与讨论
相关主题
Re: A hand on BBO.Look at this hand
JEC赛实战坐庄叫牌问题(11)
is there a grand plan?【每周一题】概率打法
Can you do better?【每周一题】保留选择
3NT at BBO【每周一题】Kill Point
how to bid【每周一题】GNT-Open 实战牌例
【每周一题】第九墩牌Some thoughts on one hand
Bidding question IIIWhat do you discard?
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: east话题: play话题: hk话题: west话题: 9830