f*****x
发帖数: 545 | 1 when you hold 4-4 in minor, which suit do you open? 2/1 or sayc. i prefer 1c,
coz i think which could save space for pd, in case he has weak hand with c
suit. but pd said i should open 1d. any comments or thoughts? or purely depend
on partnership style? | a*******s
发帖数: 295 | 2
1c,
depend
with 4-4 minor usually I open 1C, unless the singleton in spade and have
a rebid problem. In this case you open 1D so that you can rebid 2C over a
1S response.
for balanced hand with weak clubs, some choose to open 1D because they don't
like partner lead a club if your side has to defense this hand.
with 4 diamonds and 5 clubs, sometimes you still have to open 1D if you want
to
show both minors with a minimum. This method creates a problem when partner
have
doubleton in both minors,
【在 f*****x 的大作中提到】
: when you hold 4-4 in minor, which suit do you open? 2/1 or sayc. i prefer 1c,
: coz i think which could save space for pd, in case he has weak hand with c
: suit. but pd said i should open 1d. any comments or thoughts? or purely depend
: on partnership style?
| w****b
发帖数: 623 | 3 A very good question, and even in the expert circle, you get split answers,
and some of them would even have very strong opinions.
Here's my view. I think instead of a definite answer, a more useful tool is to
figure out along what lines to think, and what criteria to take. There are two
important factors in your decision: rebid & lead directing, and in that order.
arrowhits' desciption on the rebidding issue is on target. Let me explain the
lead direction consideration. When you are 3rd or some
【在 a*******s 的大作中提到】
:
: 1c,
: depend
: with 4-4 minor usually I open 1C, unless the singleton in spade and have
: a rebid problem. In this case you open 1D so that you can rebid 2C over a
: 1S response.
: for balanced hand with weak clubs, some choose to open 1D because they don't
: like partner lead a club if your side has to defense this hand.
: with 4 diamonds and 5 clubs, sometimes you still have to open 1D if you want
: to
| l*********r
发帖数: 65 | 4 My experience is, with minimum opener, open 1D.
However, with very strong hand, open 1C.
The reason is, say partner holding long clubs and not good enough to respond
1NT or 2C 1st time but too strong to pass, he will be crying. Say sth like:
xxx
xxx
x
KQJxxx
If you open 1D, partner is having a nightmare. If you open 1C he can
comfortably raise.
OK I know some of you would "borrow" a 1H bid with that hand but let's say if
your pd can tolerate such torture. Some of you might play 1D-3C as
intermed
【在 w****b 的大作中提到】
: A very good question, and even in the expert circle, you get split answers,
: and some of them would even have very strong opinions.
: Here's my view. I think instead of a definite answer, a more useful tool is to
: figure out along what lines to think, and what criteria to take. There are two
: important factors in your decision: rebid & lead directing, and in that order.
: arrowhits' desciption on the rebidding issue is on target. Let me explain the
: lead direction consideration. When you are 3rd or some
|
|
