j********r
发帖数: 156 | 1 The pre-application decisions are just released. Mine was rejected. The four
reviewers' comments seems very positive (there ARE some negative points,
which are inconsistent with each other). I wonder if there is a chance to
appeal. Can anyone share his/her experience? Thanks a lot, | q*****n
发帖数: 331 | 2 Appeal won't work normally. Even for the selected ones, 80% won't get the
grants. It is just too competetive nowadays.
Move on to something else. | T*G
发帖数: 600 | 3 Got it on last year. Tried twice, first year didn't work since the reviewers
criticized that we don't have too much expertise in breast cancer and the
proposal was too basic. I heard that appeal usually won't work
four
【在 j********r 的大作中提到】
: The pre-application decisions are just released. Mine was rejected. The four
: reviewers' comments seems very positive (there ARE some negative points,
: which are inconsistent with each other). I wonder if there is a chance to
: appeal. Can anyone share his/her experience? Thanks a lot,
| M*****n
发帖数: 16729 | | j********r
发帖数: 156 | 5 Thanks all for the nice information! So for komen, the final rate is 4% (20%
pre x 20% final)?
That would be similar to the ones of other more prestigious fellowship like
LSRF.
To TSG, did you get through the pre-application the first time you applied?
Also did you make major revisions in the second time? Thanks a lot, |
|
