J*****i
发帖数: 55 | 1 During one paper being reviewed, if another paper of similar conclusion is
published, will this work against the first paper, particularly decrease
the novelty of the first paper?
| b****r
发帖数: 17995 | 2 要是一般的杂志，我估计editor都不一定能发现别人刚刚发出来类似文章了
如果发现了，我猜要看时间有多接近吧，很接近的话可能两篇文章都会有credit，说不
定被review这篇还能因此被早点发表 | h****u
发帖数: 480 | 3
is
decrease
yes, especially if a reviewer brings up the novelty issue to the editor.
【在 J*****i 的大作中提到】
: During one paper being reviewed, if another paper of similar conclusion is
: published, will this work against the first paper, particularly decrease
: the novelty of the first paper?
:
| k*****o
发帖数: 1486 | 4 NOT AT ALL!!! A lot of great science has been published this way.
The red envelop.
Do not let others discourage you. It happens all the time. I have also seen
a paper from my lab published on a very decent journal even after a similar
report. |
|
