s*********a
发帖数: 45 | 1 can pros give some ideas about the NHTSA test?
2011 Honda odyssey NHTSA test 5 stars except rollover (4 stars)
which is better than Pilot, and way better than Sienna. So can I conclude
safety 2011 odyssey>Pilot(4WD)>Sienna?
I live in central NJ. Is Pilot(4WD)better than FWD Odyssey.
Thanks for suggestions. |
d****n
发帖数: 12461 | |
l**********t
发帖数: 5754 | 3 Not a pro but I went thru a similar decision process. The 3rd row in Pilot
is not practical -- just go to a showroom and try it -- you probably won't
fit if you are a full size grown-up. And there is not enough cargo behind
the 3rd row.
If you want a SUV seats more than 4, go for a domestic body-on-frame full
size SUV -- Suburban / Yukon / Expedition / Navigator etc. These are
probably the safest against collisions. The downside is their reliability,
maneuverability and fuel economy.
A comprise is the cross-over (Traverse & sibling) -- better handling and
fuel economy but less space behind the 3rd row, and most importantly, no
longer a body-on-frame built so it is more uni-body car like in a collision.
Minivans are designed to haul 7 to 8 people around town. They are spacious,
convenient (sliding doors!), kids-friendly, and drive like a car. But all
minivans (and sedans & crossovers) are uni-body built, which put them in a
disadvantaged position when colliding with a truck or body-on-frame SUVs at
high speed.
【在 s*********a 的大作中提到】
: can pros give some ideas about the NHTSA test?
: 2011 Honda odyssey NHTSA test 5 stars except rollover (4 stars)
: which is better than Pilot, and way better than Sienna. So can I conclude
: safety 2011 odyssey>Pilot(4WD)>Sienna?
: I live in central NJ. Is Pilot(4WD)better than FWD Odyssey.
: Thanks for suggestions.
|
R***a
发帖数: 41892 | 4 下雪的时候4WD > crash test
雪胎> 4WD
【在 s*********a 的大作中提到】
: can pros give some ideas about the NHTSA test?
: 2011 Honda odyssey NHTSA test 5 stars except rollover (4 stars)
: which is better than Pilot, and way better than Sienna. So can I conclude
: safety 2011 odyssey>Pilot(4WD)>Sienna?
: I live in central NJ. Is Pilot(4WD)better than FWD Odyssey.
: Thanks for suggestions.
|
s*********a
发帖数: 45 | 5 Thanks for sharing.
conclude
【在 s*********a 的大作中提到】
: can pros give some ideas about the NHTSA test?
: 2011 Honda odyssey NHTSA test 5 stars except rollover (4 stars)
: which is better than Pilot, and way better than Sienna. So can I conclude
: safety 2011 odyssey>Pilot(4WD)>Sienna?
: I live in central NJ. Is Pilot(4WD)better than FWD Odyssey.
: Thanks for suggestions.
|
s*********a
发帖数: 45 | 6 So is Pilot is uni-body built or body-on-frame?
Pilot
won't
behind
full
reliability,
and
no
【在 l**********t 的大作中提到】
: Not a pro but I went thru a similar decision process. The 3rd row in Pilot
: is not practical -- just go to a showroom and try it -- you probably won't
: fit if you are a full size grown-up. And there is not enough cargo behind
: the 3rd row.
: If you want a SUV seats more than 4, go for a domestic body-on-frame full
: size SUV -- Suburban / Yukon / Expedition / Navigator etc. These are
: probably the safest against collisions. The downside is their reliability,
: maneuverability and fuel economy.
: A comprise is the cross-over (Traverse & sibling) -- better handling and
: fuel economy but less space behind the 3rd row, and most importantly, no
|
M***s
发帖数: 8769 | 7 不知道座椅测试了没，去年年底那个odyssey的劣质座椅由于碰撞导致父亲的座椅断掉
把后排的三个月大的女儿砸死的事情实在是太恐怖了 |
