s*******u
发帖数: 9508 | 1 http://www.amazon.com/professor-philosophy-Princeton-reflection
In reply to an earlier post on Feb 1, 2013 7:19:11 PM PST
Erica Brindley says:
Hi Kuikui, I don't know what to say about claim #1, that she grew up in
Nanjing. It's a he-said/she-said claim, though, and why, without further
evidence, would one give preference to either claim? As for #2, the book
never states she was sent to a "child labor camp"! It is very clear that she
was taken to the NUAA, near an area near a soccer field on the... 阅读全帖 |
|
U***5
发帖数: 2796 | 2 Posted on Feb 1, 2013 8:03:14 PM PST
Erica Brindley says:
And please stop this bashing of me as a person. It is very cruel behavior
and not appropriate for a public forum. I have not bashed a single one of
you personally, and there are hundreds of you and only one of me. I liked
the book and found it profoundly moving and full of good insights. If your
hatred of the book does not stem from the Fang Zhouzi report, and you have
given the book an honest chance, then please forgive my initial statem... 阅读全帖 |
|
U***5
发帖数: 2796 | 3 再再打脸：
In reply to an earlier post on Feb 1, 2013 7:46:22 PM PST
Last edited by the author 29 minutes ago
Allon says:
!!!!(Quoted) Erica Brindley says:
I have read the book, have you? As for the online interviews, I cannot
comment. I have heard that they have twisted the story........(end of quote)
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Come on, you can not comment the straight words coming out from Ms. Ping Fu'
s mouth, but you have been so supportive and defensive for a book full of
lies. And, we are still not clear h... 阅读全帖 |
|
U***5
发帖数: 2796 | 4 老美也跳出来打脸：
In reply to an earlier post on Feb 1, 2013 7:28:34 PM PST
Thomas Miller says:
Early today, she claimed that she learnt a lot of languages. Since she claim
to have a degree in Chinese history, I assume she learnt a little bit
Chinese. Seems I am wrong, and I have no idea how she conducted independent
and innovative research which lead to a PhD degree from Princeton.....
Erica Brindley says:
In fact, 7 and 1/2 years is considered fast for those of us working
seriously on Asia. There are ... 阅读全帖 |
|
U***5
发帖数: 2796 | 5 越描越黑，
直接把方舟子的名字理解为 "Zhou Fangzi",
网友对其中文水平，以及普林斯顿中国史博士学位表示怀疑。
Erica Brindley says:
I have read the book, have you? As for the online interviews, I cannot
comment. I have heard that they have twisted the story and that Zhou Fangzi
is trying to rip into anything that doesn't present China in a favorable
light. But the main point is that there is much in there that simply cannot
be "fact-checked." It is a personal statement, a bunch of memories - she is
not presenting this as history but as somethi... 阅读全帖 |
|
p********1
发帖数: 2785 | 6 这是Amazon上Lin的评论。存在这里做个纪念：
As a Chinese, I lived through that period of time in China. I have similar
family and educational background as hers and suffered during Culture
Revolution as a child. I think her experiences in China mostly, if not all,
are fabricated, imagined, overly exaggerated or deliberately miss leading.
If one just read the media reports about her book, he/she may think that
media might just pick the sensational parts of the book and exaggerated a
little bit to help her to sell ... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
x****n
发帖数: 950 | 8 哈洛尔德·伊万斯（Harold Evans）是英国著名的新闻人，著名到什么程度呢？2000年
他被国际新闻协会评为50年来50名世界新闻自由英雄之一。2004年他因为在新闻领域的
贡献而被英国女王封为爵士。在他年轻的时候，他是英国著名的调查记者，首先报道过
多起著名事件，因为正义敢言而名噪一时。后来移居美国，担任过《大西洋月刊》《美
国新闻与世界报道》等杂志的主编，目前为路透社的非在编编辑（editor-at-large）
。其妻子是美国新闻界的重量级人物，《新闻周刊》和《野兽日报》的主编蒂娜·布朗
（Tina Brown）。
就是这么一位西方新闻界大佬，最近在《野兽日报》发表了一篇评论《傅苹的迫害
》（http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/02/11/the-persecution-of-ping-fu.html ），把世界华人对傅苹回忆录的批评称为是对傅苹的迫害。伊万斯的妻子布朗是傅苹的重要支持者，曾在美国公共电台推荐傅苹回忆录，其主办的《野兽日报》也力推过傅苹回忆录，并在傅苹受到批评时最先发表报道，违反新闻道德，用断章取义的手法把对... 阅读全帖 |
|
N*******g
发帖数: 370 | 9 一个英国著名新闻人的堕落
·方舟子·
哈洛尔德·伊万斯（Harold Evans）是英国著名的新闻人，著名到什么程度
呢？2000年他被国际新闻协会评为50年来50名世界新闻自由英雄之一。2004年他
因为在新闻领域的贡献而被英国女王封为爵士。在他年轻的时候，他是英国著名
的调查记者，首先报道过多起著名事件，因为正义敢言而名噪一时。后来移居美
国，担任过《大西洋月刊》《美国新闻与世界报道》等杂志的主编，目前为路透
社的非在编编辑（editor-at-large）。其妻子是美国新闻界的重量级人物，
《新闻周刊》和《野兽日报》的主编蒂娜·布朗（Tina Brown）。
就是这么一位西方新闻界大佬，最近在《野兽日报》发表了一篇评论《傅苹
的迫害》
（http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/02/11/the-persecution-of-
ping-fu.html ），把世界华人对傅苹回忆录的批评称为是对傅苹的迫害。伊万
斯的妻子布朗是傅苹的重要支持者，曾在美国公共电台推... 阅读全帖 |
|
k******a
发帖数: 2436 | 10 Funny thing, a name, Tom Brindley just endorsed the book.
Why are so many Foxes and Brindleys coming out? |
|
d**e
发帖数: 2420 | 11 真要感谢一下买买提的弟兄们，为他提供炮弹。
http://fangzhouzi.t.sohu.com/
傅苹的“自传”找了职业枪手Meimei Fox做共同作者，在amazon出现的5星评论中，有
一个是Meimei Fox的哥哥Derek Fox写的，另一个是Derek妻子Erica Brindley写的，
Brindley以汉学家身份保证该书的真实性，正与给1星的华人激辩。Meimei、Derek是夏
威夷众议院前少数派（共和党）领袖Galen Fox的子女，Galen因性犯罪被判刑、辞职。 |
|
L*********n
发帖数: 1225 | 12 18:01 来自腾讯微博 阅读(8.3万) 全部转播和评论(167) 转播|评论|
方舟子: 如我所料，傅苹果然是靠申请政治避难获得的绿卡。这就可以肯定她那套在中
国的悲惨经历是当天为申请政治避难编出来的。《星岛日报》去年2月的报道：【杰魔
公司华裔董事长傅苹出生在中国大陆，成长于文革时期，1983年来美国后申请了难民庇
护得到身分，之后创立了自己的公司。】http://url.cn/A9cvaS
昨天 15:21 来自腾讯微博 阅读(5.8万) 全部转播和评论(95) 转播|评论|
更多
方舟子: 傅苹10天前接受谷歌视频采访时，亲口说自己文革10年都生活在古拉格（即劳
改营），现在则说劳改营是记者乱说。在该视频采访中她还说她因为论文被抓，在邓小
平（！）的过问下才被释放，两周后公安给了她护照要求她离开中国。现在她说为办护
照她拖了一年多才离开中国。http://url.cn/DGszZg
昨天 14:48 来自腾讯微博 阅读(27万) 全部转播和评论(267) 转播|评论|
更多
方舟子: 傅苹“自传”找职业枪手Meimei Fox做共同作者，在amazon的5星评论中，有
一个是... 阅读全帖 |
|
d**e
发帖数: 2420 | 13 http://fangzhouzi.t.sohu.com/
Brindley是以普林斯顿大学博士、中国研究权威的身份出来公开支持傅苹的，发现自己
判断有误不再吭声不是负责任的做法。 //@程鹗 这几天一直在与Erica Brindley教授
私信交流讨论。她态度诚恳，看法已经有所转变，但感情上还无法接受傅苹是骗子这一
点。她表示不再有时间精力公开参与此事。这些讨论信件也已经转交给Meimei Fox。 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 14 The tight-knit motorcycle community was reeling Sunday after a horrific
collision left seven people dead and three injured in a remote area of
northern New Hampshire.
The group of 10 motorcycles collided with a pickup towing a flatbed trailer
on Route 2 around 6:30 p.m. Friday in the small town of Randolph. The pickup
caught fire, and witnesses described the scene as "devastating."
Dawn Brindley, a woman riding with the group, survived the crash after
getting off her bike and rolling away, New H... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
k******a
发帖数: 2436 | 16 Funny the full name is Erica Fox Brindley (google it). They are all from the
same family? |
|
|
c*****r
发帖数: 2866 | 18 Sister in law
http://www.aloha.net/~gfox/bio/
Galen has two grown children, Derek and MeiMei. Derek is currently
working in Pasadena and married to Ms. Erica Brindley. MeiMei is married
to Dale Fox and they live in Los Angeles, CA. |
|
|
|
k******y
发帖数: 1407 | 21 这人的逻辑就是：
为什么圣经没有错？
Because the bible says so!
唉⋯⋯普林斯顿貌似有个中国中心⋯⋯真心不知道到底干了些什么
she
27)
had |
|
t****t
发帖数: 820 | 22 此女好像丢下一句话就从论坛里面撤退了.
她的反驳很弱. 明明chapter 1第一句话就是说被deported, 她还反驳说书上没写中国
政府送她出国. |
|
q**w
发帖数: 782 | 23 这婊子和那本书的coauthor是亲戚关系
she
27)
had |
|
k*******r
发帖数: 16963 | 24 呵呵，去评论就问她和那个书作者美美是啥关系就够了。Y被人肉了还不知道。 |
|
s*******u
发帖数: 9508 | 25 我其实怀疑这个狗屎教授也是ghost writer之一。。 |
|
U***5
发帖数: 2796 | 26 打脸：
In reply to an earlier post on Feb 1, 2013 7:54:04 PM PST
Last edited by the author 4 minutes ago
Wing says:
"#4 The book never states the Chinese govt sent her to America." ---- Erica,
I am disappointed. Enlighten me, since you have read the book, how do you
interpret this sentence: When I was 25 years old, the Chinese government
quietly deported me, which happens to be the first sentence of the entire
book.
You have, in the very first post of this thread, put your profession at
stake, so I... 阅读全帖 |
|
k*******r
发帖数: 16963 | 27 宜将剩勇追穷寇，不可沽名学霸王。
丫自己是个sb亲友团还说大家是水军。 |
|
U***5
发帖数: 2796 | 28 再打脸：
In reply to an earlier post on Feb 1, 2013 7:57:39 PM PST
crasher says:
Please, Erica, do a research to find out who Fang Zhouzi is (you can't even
spell his name right) and what he has been doing.
Also, please do send a book to Mr. Fang.
Erica, |
|
|
U***5
发帖数: 2796 | 30 这个直接从专业上打脸：
Posted on Feb 1, 2013 6:52:51 PM PST
Last edited by the author 1 hour ago
Xianyi says:
Dear Erica,
Do you think you are the only professor teaching Chinese history here? Come
on, show me your knowledge on American historiography on the Cultural
Revolution and show me your expertise in oral history, Foucaultdian theory,
memory and identity. You simply dismiss all the discussants here because you
cannot answer one important question:
When you said you were a Princeton PhD in Chinese hi... 阅读全帖 |
|
s*******u
发帖数: 9508 | 31 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/ping-fu/sad-but-not-broken_b_2603
TenTenElevenBecome a fan
.
.
.
.
.
0 Fans.
1. You confirmed to Forbes you waited 1 year before getting the passport.
And in your google interview, you said you got your passport in 2 weeks. Can
you explain the timeline discrepancy?
2. Were you deported from China, or voluntarily came to US to study?
3. Did you witness your teacher being quartered by 4 horses during the
revolution? One of your friends Mrs. Erica Brindley has ackno... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
c******k
发帖数: 8998 | 33 那个Erica Brindley现在也不要脸了 |
|
U***5
发帖数: 2796 | 34 Brindley 是第一个跳出来战斗在马鬃书评的，也是被打脸打得最狠的。
后面的评分升高降低，跟她基本没关系了。 |
|
p********1
发帖数: 2785 | 35 User:ParisaprilFrom Wikipedia, the free encyclopediaJump to: navigation,
search [edit] Ping Fu Controversy[edit] SummaryPing Fu is a Chinese American
business woman, currently resides in the United States. She is the co-
founder and CEO of Geomagic, a 3D software company. Her memoir "Bend, Not
Break - A Life in Two Worlds" described her journey from China's Cultural
Revolution to a high tech CEO in America. However, upon the memoir
publication, a major controversy erupted over the author's depic... 阅读全帖 |
|
w*p
发帖数: 16484 | 36 这书应该搞2本寄给Meimei Fox和Erica Brindley |
|
d*****l
发帖数: 8441 | 37 脊髓损伤后膀胱功能重建的基础与应用研究
上海长征医院侯春林等
点评：研究人员探索不同脊髓损伤平面造成的不同类型神经源性膀胱功能重建方法
，在临床上用以改善截瘫病人排尿功能，提高其健康水平和生活质量。在国际上首次报
导利用脊髓损伤平面以下残存的腱反射并用于临床实践，发明了人工排尿报警装置并获
国家发明专利。
丁香园会员问：
前几年，武汉协和医院肖传 国教授研究了自主神经和体神经的移植，建立人工反射弧
，恢复脊髓损伤后的膀胱功能，得了国家科技进步二等奖。您的工作和他的研究有何异
同？盼指教，谢谢！
侯春林答：
武汉协和医院的肖 传国教授于1994年在国际上最先提出了反射弧的概念，但他是利用
截瘫平面以上的浅反射――皮肤反射弧。我是于1996年开始这项工作，根据临床上高位
脊髓损伤（颈髓和胸髓）的特点，首次提出了可以利用截瘫平面以下的深反射――腱反
射建立人工膀胱反射弧，并开展了实验研究和临床研究，在国内外首先报道了临床上利
用截瘫平面以上腱反射重建人工膀胱反射弧恢复脊髓损伤患者排尿功能。另外，针对脊
髓损伤后膀胱功能障碍的不同类型，分别进行了（1）选择性骶神经切断术（2）在国内
率先开展B... 阅读全帖 |
|
